thehefner: (Two-Face: FOREVER!!!)
[personal profile] thehefner posting in [community profile] scans_daily
Back when I posted Two-Face: Year One--which entirely cut out the character of Harvey's wife, Gilda--one commenter asked if any kind of wife/finance is really needed for Harvey.

Me, I'd argue that Gilda is a character who is absolutely essential to displaying the humanity and core tragedy of Harvey Dent. Unfortunately, she's made very few appearances in comics, which I think is a major reason why Two-Face is so often written as a one-note monster with a cheap gimmick.

That said, Gilda can be a problematic character. When she first appeared in the original Harvey Kent trilogy way back in the 40's, her character was mainly there to be the weeping, faithful, fragile love interest, the pure-hearted woman who could redeem Harvey through the sheer power of lurve.

Two-Face eventually returned, but Gilda did not. At least, not until 1980, after a thirty-six year absence, in the story I bring you today. In this overly-convoluted mystery entitled Double Jeopardy/Twice Dies the Batman, Gilda meets a new love interest with a shady past, and unwittingly becomes involved in a web of lies, murder, and revenge. Why can't there ever be webs of nice things, like puppies and pie?

Note: These scans are from Batman #328-329.

The film runs out, leaving Alfred simply appalled and wondering why on earth this person would go through all the trouble of staging a recreation (with actors? Cardboard cutouts? Where'd he get the budget?) just to taunt Batman.

But we already know that wasn't the case! So now that this murderous, mysterious Mr. Ternion is flaunting his freedom, what diabolical deeds could he be dood'in at that very moment?!

Would you believe... a quiet carriage ride in the park with his lady friend?

So, we get a lot of info right away about what happened to Gilda after Harvey became Two-Face again (although the story is written in such a way that I think it's supposed be a *surprise* that she's that Gilda talking about that Harvey): she remarried, to none other than Harvey's former assistant! We're getting allusions to a whole backstory that we've never and will never see.

Yes, that is indeed the same Dr. Ekhart who was mentioned all the way back in Harvey and Gilda's first appearance.

As you may recall, the reason he couldn't perform plastic surgery on Harvey the first time was because Ekhart was captured by the Nazis and put in a concentration camp. So basically, Ekhart never could get a break. And now if they ever use him in a Two-Face comic again, readers will assume it's just an Aaron Eckhart reference. Poor, dead, brilliant plastic surgeon.

Batman finds Ekhart's body, and realizes who Ternion really is. By the way, Ternion means "three." I looked it up because, seriously, the only reason a character would have a name as awkward as "Ternion" would be so the writer to make some "clever" allusion.

That said, I'm still not sure what's up with the name "Karoselle." He... goes round and round? I got nothin'.

... Look, sorry to distract from the DRAMATIC SURPRISE TWIST REVEAL here, but seriously, plastic surgery does not work that way.

It doesn't unravel and instantly revert to what it was before. I keep hearing Moe Syzlak: "Hey, there's one thing I don't get though. When my face was crushed, why did it go back to my old face? I mean, shouldn't I have turned into some kind of third face that was different?" *CUT TO CREDITS*

Have you figured out why Karoselle would possibly have the newspaper clipping of Maroni's death at Harvey's hands (or rather, coin)? I'm not sure how in the world you would, but apparently Batman has.

He tracks down Gilda, explaining the situation to her off-panel while Harvey, spying from an adjacent rooftop, goes on a raving angstfest that isn't worth showing here. Which Batman notices.

Wait, cripple? What? Yes, apparently, back in the Dave Davis story, Maroni survived being shot by Harvey (or rather, the bullet which deflected off Harvey's coin in mid-air, because physics totally work that way), but the bullet left him paralyzed from the waist down, ironically turning the man who created Two-Face into "half a man." The story's words, not mine. Now, the emphasis of Maroni's hatred is directly back on Harvey, which serves as his entire motive throughout the mystery. Oh, was that a spoiler?

Harvey chases "Maroni" (really Batman in disguise) and Gilda (playing along) into his old courthouse, wondering how the mobster could still be alive after Harvey had "killed him twice."

That has to be the single most hardcore thing that Harvey's ever done.

While recovering from surgery, Harvey went through Ekhart's files and found info on Karoselle, wherein reveals that Karoselle was really none other than Boss Maroni himself! Therefore, Maroni/Karoselle had murdered Dave Stevens as a way of hurting Harvey by hurting Gilda.

Back in the present time, Harvey realizes that this "Maroni" cannot be the real one (what with him walking and all), and exposes the impostor as Batman. Harvey even manages to get Batman at his mercy (or perhaps Batman lets him, since he doesn't want to win this with fists), as Batman tries to talk reason into Two-Face:

... Damn! All of a sudden, Gilda goes from a miserable ball of self-pity and martyrdom to a strong, determined character who's fed up and ready--appropriately enough--to law down the law.

She's no longer pining, waiting, praying for her poor, poor lost beloved Harvey to come back to her. She'd lost him once already. She was moving on with her life. Then forces both in and outside of Harvey's control made her life worse than ever, and after much wallowing, she takes it upon herself to break the chain.

She's now putting it directly to Harvey in a way that, incidentally, hits at the core of Harvey's madness: his ability/inability to choose. Thing is, Gilda is the only person capable of reaching Harvey in this manner. Batman's trying (just as he always tries), but he's about to fail (just as he always fails), because neither he nor anyone but Gilda ever had a strong emotional bond to pre-crazy Harvey.

Gilda, simply put, is his lifeline. If there's to be any hope for him to be redeemed, any reason for why he should keep fighting and not kill himself or let the madness consume him utterly... it's her.

Oh, and Alfred was along as well, but I had to cut out his part. He helped. Batman tells Alfred that there are times when he questions if all his efforts are for naught, "but then... times like this justify all the horrors and all the hells. Now let's go home. For a change, I think it's going to be a good night!"

God, I love Bronze Age Batman. Maybe I'm just soured by too many post-Miller iterations of Batman as hard and unforgiving--particularly his hardline stance against Hal Jordan since the 90's--but I just can't imagine the Batman of today putting himself on the line to maybe, possibly, save the soul of a once-good man.

The story ends on such a hopeful note that you almost forget how it won't go anywhere. Indeed, this resolution isn't even mentioned by the time Two-Face returns for his next scheme two years later. That said, Wolfman himself makes mention of how Harvey gave up crime in A Lonely Place of Dying (although he wrote that Harvey did so at the coin's behest), right before having him take up crime once more.

Okay, now that it's over, I have to say that I found this story a bit convoluted and awkwardly handled (and my hack/slash edits of the scans couldn't have helped). There was a good story here, but it was chopped up and Frankensteined together with blocks of bald-faced exposition.

I almost feel like this is story--this frickin' saga, really--should have been told in linear fashion. Perhaps it could have been a subplot simmering between main Batman stories, much like the return of Rupert Thorne storyline (which I'll be posting soon in the Hugo Strange series). It could have been Harvey's own version of Going Sane!

That's the story I'd want to see. As it is, we have it torn to pieces and lumped back together as a mystery for Batman to solve, rather than a journey for these characters to take.

In the near future, I'll post the one other story to actually make use of this refreshing new direction for Gilda before she's relegated back to her previous characterization... or worse, in the case of the story from which she's now, regrettably, most famous.

Date: 2010-12-01 04:56 am (UTC)
From: [personal profile] psychopathicus_rex
The impression I got was that it DIDN'T 'just unravel and instantly revert to what it was before' - instead, there was some minor sign of the surgery undoing itself; an unusual tightening of the skin, perhaps, or his lips on the left side of his face only moving with difficulty into any position other than their previous snarl. To anyone other than Harvey, it would have been virtually unnoticeable, but, hyper-sensitive to such things, he DID notice - and flipped out. With his face in his hands, he runs out, obsessively feeling, pinching, tugging, trying to convince himself through tactile proof that he's wrong, that his face is just fine. It is THIS that 'unravels' his plastic surgery - he essentially rips it apart in an effort to convince himself that it's still holding up.
Of course, his hair still shouldn't have changed color in the process - but hey, artistic license.
Also - who's Moe Syzlak? The name sounds vaguely familiar, but I can't place him.

Date: 2010-12-01 01:06 pm (UTC)
From: [personal profile] psychopathicus_rex
I aim to please.
Oh, HIM, right. I almost never see 'The Simpsons', and when I do, everyone just tends to call him 'Moe'.


scans_daily: (Default)
Scans Daily


Founded by girl geeks and members of the slash fandom, [community profile] scans_daily strives to provide an atmosphere which is LGBTQ-friendly, anti-racist, anti-ableist, woman-friendly and otherwise discrimination and harassment free.

Bottom line: If slash, feminism or anti-oppressive practice makes you react negatively, [community profile] scans_daily is probably not for you.

Please read the community ethos and rules before posting or commenting.

September 2017

      1 2
3 4 5 6 7 8 9
10 11 12 13 14 15 16
17 18 19 20212223

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags