I assure you - we do work very hard at being correct! And I have to point out, just because you aren't persuaded, it doesn't mean that our argument isn't persuasive.

We strongly feel that discussion of people's daughters who have never done anything to involve themselves in the comic book profession and who may well be underage (we don't have information about her, and we don't want it - we do not want this to be a community that searches out personal info on real people in, especially in the name of complaining) is not something we want in scans daily. This is partly for the reason we've previously spoken to members about (it can lead to pettiness and inappropriate speculation and we'd rather prevent that than cure it) and partly just because this is a comic book community, not a gossip community. We aren't the only comics discussion community on the net so if anyone feels they really MUST talk about who people are named after, there are PLENTY of places to do it - we aren't oppressing members by asking that family members remain uninvoked.

Our policies of avoiding personal insult back up our mod consensus that members rolling eyes in comments about a father-daughter connection is just something that goes against the friendly space that we strive to keep s_d as.

Thank you for your civility! It's good to know that members who dislike certain decisions can still abide by them without ire.