cyberghostface: (Spidey & MJ)
[personal profile] cyberghostface posting in [community profile] scans_daily

This is the second part of 'Carnage', with issues #63 to #65.

So Aunt May returns home to find no one there. She realizes something is off and discovers...

The backyard is being swarmed with police. Peter and May are questioned about what went on, and another cop mentions similar things that have gone on at Empire State University and Manhattan. 'Vampiric' and 'mutant' are being tossed around.

There's a bit more dealing with grief; Mary Jane talks to Peter, who assures him that he was still a good friend to Gwen. Peter wonders what's the point of being Spider-Mani if he can't save the ones closest to him.

Later, Peter is considering all the possible people behind Gwen's death, when he remembers Empire State University. He sees Curt Connors standing outside his house (right now Peter is at Mary Jane's) and runs out and attacks him. Peter assumes that Connors had done something as the Lizard, but Connors explains there was an accident at the lab.

Next issue...

Yeah, Carnage was a lot more intimidating when he was silent and wasn't yelling "Beh!"

Peter says to himself how he has failed at keeping Uncle Ben's mantra of "with great power comes great responsibility". Carnage flees and kills two cops, before turning into a naked version of Peter.

Later, Connors is back in his lab when he finds Peter there. Peter tells him "It's done". Connors asks what happened, and Peter explains via flashback:

Peter tells Connors how the creature wasn't a was an spore, an airborne virus. It didn't have a brain or a soul, and it didn't belong here. Peter lures it to a smoke stack.

Connors apologizes to Peter, who almost attacks him in response for his responsibility in Carnage and Gwen's death, but he restrains himself.

Later, Connors turns himself in.

Connor is taken into custody, his lab is closed but at the end of the issue, his lab assistant is seen pocketing Peter's blood samples.

So contrast to Venom, who I think in some ways works better than the standard 616 version, I think Bendis dropped the ball with Carnage. With the exception of Gwen's death, I don't think Ultimate Carnage would really have been a memorable villain and the whole thing comes off as a bad horror film at times. I do think the backstory of Carnage being an experiment was interesting, but Venom had that too.

One of the funniest things is how much contempt Bendis has for 616 Carnage, saying stuff like "I don't think it's impossible to tell a good story with Carnage, it just hasn't been done yet" and how this would be an improvement. Say what you want about Cletus, but at least he's fun to read sometimes with his crazy antics. Personally, given Bendis's tenure as a crime writer (especially Torso) I think a serial killer in an an alien suit would have been up his alley and he could have made it work.

Next issue was an 'epilogue' of sorts with Peter and friends in detention (long story). It had this opening scene:

One more 'interlude' post left before I can post the return of Venom.


Date: 2011-05-18 11:14 pm (UTC)
drmcninja: (Default)
From: [personal profile] drmcninja
I always saw carnage as symbol of what Peter could become, in the worst possible way. Venom (Brock) has his moments on either side, generally like this Carnage, where he goes through just trying to survive and sort things out, figuring out what he should be. Carnage to me, has always been "what if peter had no responsibility. What if he used his powers in the most selfish, crazy way possible." Carnage has this insane power, and he got it through a sheer accident, just like Peter did, and all he does is use it to do whatever he wants. He is the epitome of what an evil spider man would be, and thats why I think he works.

Date: 2011-05-19 12:24 am (UTC)
damianwayne: (Default)
From: [personal profile] damianwayne
An evil Spider-Man has so much more potential though. Carnage wasn't anything like Peter and it makes for a much less interesting killer. Kasady was played as a 90's metalhead with a blood fetish -"Yeah baby! Anarchy! Woo, let's blast the new Guns n Roses while we slit a guy's throat and use his blood to write "sweet child of mine!" at the crime scene! That's DARK!"

It really wasn't, though. It was stupid.

IMO? You want to make an evil Spider-Man, it starts with a mirror not of Spidey but of Peter. The guy who gets the Carnage symbiote isn't Otto from the Simpsons, but a genius bookish, social outcast. Kicked all the way up the ladder, never noticed by girls or guys alike. Make him a devious serial killer who acts as a "hero" during the day, stopping petty supervillains, but also solving his own gruesome murders. Hell, introduce him as someone trying to help Spidey out, then the reveal. Maybe Spidey finds out his civvie identity inadvertently and then starts to piece together that this was a disturbed individual. He doesn't even know that it's been the Carnage symbiote, because this kid was actually batshit insane enough to [tame] it. Then Pete tracks him to his family home home on a hunch, nd finds, I unno, a bunch of victims cocooned up in cacaphony of webbing, being fed on by the kid and his hundreds of pet spiders. That could be a cool story.

Maximum Carnage wasn't. I read it too, I was 10 and the crossover had like every Marvel hero I loved drawing at the time, and a bitching Sega Genesis tie-in. With the nostalgia glasses off, though... it was still dreck.

Date: 2011-05-19 01:01 am (UTC)
drmcninja: (Default)
From: [personal profile] drmcninja
I won't disagree. I think what I said was more my own personal canon, because as much as I can see it in the character itself, there is very little contextual evidence to work with that. The closest I can get to an actual parallel is the accidental powers: what if someone else had been bitten? But thats a tenuous link at best. The problem is still the nineties, when every slightly-obscure villain was written into a nutcase psychopath. Carnage had the bonus of being a new character, but guys like Reaper got destroyed. I just feel like they wasted so much potential with Carnage. He's got a great look, he's got really great powers, but I will not accept that they made him that over-the-top crazy because they felt like it. It seems like a waste of the chractaer, so I tend to roll with my version. This way, when something decent finally gets done with him, I can be all "I told you so."


scans_daily: (Default)
Scans Daily


Founded by girl geeks and members of the slash fandom, [community profile] scans_daily strives to provide an atmosphere which is LGBTQ-friendly, anti-racist, anti-ableist, woman-friendly and otherwise discrimination and harassment free.

Bottom line: If slash, feminism or anti-oppressive practice makes you react negatively, [community profile] scans_daily is probably not for you.

Please read the community ethos and rules before posting or commenting.

May 2016

1 2 3 4 5 6 7
8 9 10 11 12 13 14
15 16 17 18 19 20 21
22 23 24 25262728

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags