Also, I really don't recall seeing tons of jokes about how Peter should be killed because he's being written OOC or drawn poorly. If they've been abundant on the Spiderman threads, I'd really like some links, please.

I've made quite a few of them. In particular, when Ultimate Spider-Man died, I said "It should have been the other one." and numerous other people said "Hear hear." I've said that I wanted Norman Osborn to kill him during Dark Reign. Etc.

Carlie's an annoying Mary Sue, but NuPeter is a complete asshole.