Oh, you definitely couldn't hold Rogue accountable in any meaningful way. That's my point.

And the only reason this drama is about Rogue & The X Men is because that's who the writer wanted it to be about. That drama was always done on the X Men's terms.

I was just asking if the victim (in this case, Carol) was given a voice in the recovery process. That's a legit question. Victims of physical assault -- even if the perp is really, really, sorry -- sometimes get a say. Or, if the X Men decided that Rogue was forgiven, she felt guilty, and all was well. Clearly, it's a rhetorical question. Charles knows best. :-)