[personal profile] ebailey140 posting in [community profile] scans_daily
As we've seen with the debates with this post...


...there's a bit of controversy regarding the direction of the Bat books. Some object to Bruce not being a loner. What's with these groups and others wearing the Bat symbol? What's with people looking to Batman as an inspiration when he's just supposed to scare the crap out of everybody, good and evil aike? Bruce publicly funding superheroes? What's with that candle swearing ceremony thing?

They all date back decades, in some cases almost as long as Batman has existed.

A look back...

Batman: Created by Bob Kane, not Frank Miller

In the mid-1980s, DC restarted their Universe with Crisis on Infinite Earths, which re-defined the DCU for the Iron Age of Comics. As various characters and series were subsequently rebooted, decades worth of history was thrown out. Batman was redefined by Frank Miller. This Grimdark paranoid constantly angry version was very popular, and would be Batman for the next 20 years.

Then, the Iron Age ended. And, like CoIE, the DCU would be redefined for the new era with a big event, Infinite Crisis. The biggest change was acknowledging that these characters had been around for more than two decades. Frank Miller's Batman was no longer seen as the one and only possible take on the character. There was a rich history that pre-dated Miller, and it could now be drawn on.

What we're seeing now comes from the Golden, Silver, Bronze, and, yes, even the Iron Ages.

Batman as inspiration

But, some argue, Batman is all about fear, not inspiring people to help others and make the world a better place. Well, let's look at Batman's origin...

Later, we'd learn he'd fallen into what became the Batcave at an early age, where he first saw the bats. Oh, and note the candle when the young Bruce is making his promise.

He shortly took a child under his wing who had also lost his parents to criminals. We'll be getting into him in a bit...

But, one's parents don't have to be murdered to create a traumatic childhood. Sometimes, living parents provide the trauma. And one destined to become a Bat finds their inspiration...

Hmm... I think we also see why Steph's so fond of Kara. :)

Then there's Kate, whose childhood trauma was the murder of her mother and, so she thought, her twin sister. She intended to dedicate her life to protecting others by serving in the military like her parents, but her sexual orientation ended that. Then, one night...

Kate explains...

So, yes, striking fear into the hearts of criminals. But, he also inspires others to take up his cause, to make the world a better place. The Bat symbol only represents terror to those who deserve it. To others, it represents the light fighting back the darkness.

Robins, Batgirls, and others

There are those that argue that having help "devalues" Batman, that he's best as a Grimdark Loner, like he used to be. Because, you know, he was a Grimdark Loner for such a long time...

A whole year, he went without help. One year out of his 72 year history. But those 71 years don't count, right?

Even Frank Miller thought he needed a Robin. And he gave him an especially cute one.

Aside from providing back-up and, if need be, rescue, Robin keeps Batman human.

Over the years, the Batman Family grew...

OK, but going international, uniting people from around the world that he inspired, and leading them in this Club of Heroes? Where did Morrison come up with that crazy idea?

Well, OK, fine, but that was the Golden Age. It's not like there were spin-off teams during the glorious Grimdark Iron Age...

All Batman Inc really is is taking the groups that have been there for years; the Batman Family, the Club of Heroes, the Outsiders, and the Birds of Prey; and giving them a central organizaton. Makes sense, really.

But, why does Bruce think he needs to train people? It takes away from his coolness, some argue, if he's not fighting the good fight, alone. We'll let Bruce, himself, explain...

These people he's inspired took this task upon themselves. They chose to do this, with or without Bruce's help. So, by training them, he not only has help, not only has people to continue the fight once he's gone, but he makes sure they know what they're doing.

Batman isn't a psycho taking out his rage on his targets, as some would like him to be. Yes, the deaths of his parents inspired him. It inspired him to try to make the world a better place. Bruce does more than fight crime. The Wayne Foundation helps operate free clinics, schools, orphanages, soup kitchens, and the arts.

But, what about publicly financing and backing a superhero group? Well, this isn't the first time. There's this other group. You may have heard of them...

What? No, I do not just use any excuse to post a George Perez drawing of Diana. It just... illustrated my point is all. Beautifully. Sigh... Um, where was I?

Oh yeah... Financing Batman Inc won't make Bruce any more a target than he already is. Lex Luthor, during the Bruce Wayne: Fugitive arc, was out to destroy Bruce, not Batman.

The candle ceremony

Someone in the other thread described swearing new members in with a candle as like a religious cult. This dates way back. Remember, it was with a candle lit that the young Bruce swore to avenge the deaths of his parents and dedicated his life to his cause.

Then, a few issues later, came this...

We didn't see this ceremony again until recently, when Barbara decided to revive it...

Barbara's narration, explanation, and, most importantly, the shopkeeper's expression pretty much say it all.

Sticking to the Iron Age approach in 2011 would have been about as good an idea as sticking to the Bronze Age approach would have been in 1986, or sticking to the Silver Age approach would have been in 1971. Times change, and Batman has always changed with them, reflecting the era. However, he's always retained the core of what makes him Batman. And, he'll continue to do so.

Scans from Detective Comics #33, 38, 859, 860; Secret Origins 80 Page Giant #1, The Dark Knight Returns #2, Robin #92, Justice League of America #200, and Batgirl v3 #3

Date: 2011-05-13 01:26 pm (UTC)
icon_uk: (Default)
From: [personal profile] icon_uk
-building spy satellites to keep his friends and colleagues in line

Yeah, that army of semi-autonomous BatBots he's built isn't going to come back to bite him on the ass at all.

-making a major effort to make new friends and allies

Allies perhaps, subordinates, more likely, friends, not really seeing that so far.

-integrating his public and private personas

I don't see that as being a major change, ideally, both his public and private personae are shell's for Bruce Wayne at the core.

-actually looking like he is having fun with his job again

True, but every time he looks like he's having fun, he's also looking like a smug control freak again.

So yes, he is way less dickish, and being autocratic and not wanting to hang around with his (terrible) biological son aren't enough to detract from that.

I'm not talking about Damian, I'm talking about Dick. and terible or not, he is his son and, as Dick is apparently the only one to have noticed, Damian has such an enormous NEED to be wanted and accepted by his father that it's probably visible from space.

the Return of Bruce Wayne tie-ins were complete nonsense that had nothing to do with the main story and had nothing to do with anything at all that ever happened then or since, so seriously who cares about them.

We, the readership, were expected to, it was apparently the new status quo setting series, and was advertised and sold as such. The fact you didn't like it in no way changes it's supposed import (We all have series/runs like that).

Date: 2011-05-13 02:54 pm (UTC)
sadoeuphemist: (Default)
From: [personal profile] sadoeuphemist
No, the bat bots seriously aren't going to bite him in the ass at all. Because he didn't program them with a list of all his friends and their powers and the order to attack them in if necessary.

Seriously robots are not the problem here, Bruce being insane and borderline hostile to everyone around him was the problem. Enjoying being in control =/= constantly thinking up plans to take down everyone close to you. If you literally think he is not any less dickish than before, I don't know what to say to you.

In the Return of Bruce Wayne # 6:
-Batman returns from the future wearing a sterile "bush suit" that has been infected by the Hyper-Adapter, arriving very obviously in the middle of the Justice League in order to deliberately ask them for their help, having realized the value of friendship.

In the Return of Bruce Wayne tie-ins:
-Batman returns from the future with a future suit that duplicates the power of the Justice League and no one knows he's there and he spies on everyone like a weirdo.

I don't know what the hell editorial was doing but the two of them are practically opposites, and if I have to chose between accepting the main book or accepting the tie-ins, I am going to go for the main book every time.


scans_daily: (Default)
Scans Daily


Founded by girl geeks and members of the slash fandom, [community profile] scans_daily strives to provide an atmosphere which is LGBTQ-friendly, anti-racist, anti-ableist, woman-friendly and otherwise discrimination and harassment free.

Bottom line: If slash, feminism or anti-oppressive practice makes you react negatively, [community profile] scans_daily is probably not for you.

Please read the community ethos and rules before posting or commenting.

October 2017

1 2 3 4 5 6 7
8 9 10 11 12 13 14
15 16 17 18 19 2021

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags