DAILIES AWARDS VOTE!
Mar. 25th, 2011 05:29 pm![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
elf posting in ![[community profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/community.png){kind=small}
scans_daily
All in one post, because DW's character-per-post limit is huge. Formatting errors, if any, are mine; content errors, if any, belong to
salad_barbarian, and if so, we're both sorry.Voting will be open until March 30.
Open to: Registered Users, detailed results viewable to: All, participants: 74
Most Original Idea
Batman, Inc.
29 (46.0%)
Flashpoint
3 (4.8%)
Colleen Coover comics at Taco Bell
24 (38.1%)
First Wave (Batman and Doc Savage)
7 (11.1%)
Most Unsubtle Subtext
Conner and Tim Drake in Teen Titans 92
23 (34.3%)
Birds of Prey #6 Black Canary makes Huntress promise to tell Oracle and Green Arrow that Dinah loves them
12 (17.9%)
Iron Man and Captain America at the end of Avengers Prime #5
13 (19.4%)
Diana taking inspiration from Superman
10 (14.9%)
Bruce being responsible for the "birth" of Oracle
0 (0.0%)
Spidey being the poor man beaten down by society....again and again
9 (13.4%)
Best Use of Continuity
Unwritten
11 (17.5%)
Grant Morrison's Batman& Son + Return of Bruce Wayne run
15 (23.8%)
Booster Gold
37 (58.7%)
Most Creative Use of Powers
Legion of Super-Villains 1 - Zymyr warping in two planets to destroy a third
29 (58.0%)
Venom as a secret agent
21 (42.0%)
Hell Yeah-Moment of The Year - For teen and adult comics
Steph Brown slaps Bruce Wayne in Batgirl: Return of Bruce Wayne
41 (60.3%)
Peter Parker telling Norman Osborn to shut up with a cold clock to the face: Siege #3
16 (23.5%)
Boodikka smacking down cyborg supes in her mind
1 (1.5%)
Arisia punching a Guardian after blackest night
6 (8.8%)
Irey and Jesse Quick showing up during the fight with Zoom
1 (1.5%)
Skaar hugging his dad, Bruce Banner
3 (4.4%)
Heck Yeah-Moment of The Year - For all ages titles
Cass Cain and Jason as the Red Hood join the Tiny Titans cast
36 (54.5%)
Red Robin beats Ra's Al Ghul, saves everyone and Wayne Enterprises
21 (31.8%)
Aw Yeah! Titans on Multiple Earths
9 (13.6%)
Most Life Affirming Title - as opposed to GrimmDark for teens and adults
Warm and Fuzzy -most life affirming title for all ages
Tiny Titans
28 (43.1%)
Avengers Vs. Pet Avengers
9 (13.8%)
Thor the Might Avenger
15 (23.1%)
Incredible Hulks
1 (1.5%)
Thor and Warriors Four
12 (18.5%)
Best Sound Effect of The Year
Seat!~ in Tiny Titans 33
13 (19.4%)
Just about anything from Heroic Age: Prince of Power #1
26 (38.8%)
“Fap” Batman and Robin #20 Bruce grabs the remote control during the movie night with the boys
26 (38.8%)
Incredible Hulk 611 during the fight
2 (3.0%)
Best Action Sequence
Wolverine and Jubilee fighting each other in Wolverine & Jubilee #2
8 (16.0%)
Black Canary & Batman versus Calculator's hired guns at Birds of Prey #8
10 (20.0%)
Huntress vs. Shiva in Birds of Prey
11 (22.0%)
Frau Totemkinder vs Mr Dark
13 (26.0%)
Incredible Hulk 611
8 (16.0%)
Best Non-Traced Likeness to Actor
Superman & Christopher Reeve, Superman Secret Origin by Gary Frank
22 (44.9%)
Honey West #1-2
2 (4.1%)
Ultimate Nick Fury as always
25 (51.0%)
Think of The Children: Best (non-creepy) visual depiction of pre-adolescent children
Damian Wayne in Teen Titans
12 (18.5%)
Damian Wayne and Colin in Streets of Gotham
19 (29.2%)
Thor and the Warriors Four
19 (29.2%)
Rani, Booster Gold
15 (23.1%)
Best New Costume - both new characters and revamps
Solstice
19 (32.8%)
Wonder Woman
14 (24.1%)
Batman Bruce Wayne
15 (25.9%)
Mon-El's Green Lantern costume
10 (17.2%)
Worst New Costume - both new characters and revamps
Wonder Woman
19 (28.8%)
Arsenal
24 (36.4%)
Bruce Wayne's metal codpiece
7 (10.6%)
Spiderman's Tron suit
16 (24.2%)
Best New Character
Solstice
14 (23.7%)
Nightrunner
20 (33.9%)
Jackson Hyde, the new Aqualad
17 (28.8%)
Flash Thompson Venom
8 (13.6%)
Best Character Resurrection
Mera (figuratively)
21 (36.2%)
*12* returns to life in Blackest Night
5 (8.6%)
Bruce Wayne-Return of Bruce Wayne
22 (37.9%)
Jade
10 (17.2%)
Character We'd Like to See in More Titles
Cassandra Cain
34 (47.2%)
Jason Todd
10 (13.9%)
Lois Lane
4 (5.6%)
Vixen
2 (2.8%)
Grace Choi
2 (2.8%)
Amanda Waller
3 (4.2%)
Conner Hawke
5 (6.9%)
Dr. Light (Kimiyo Hoshi)
5 (6.9%)
Mia Dearden
5 (6.9%)
Booster Gold
2 (2.8%)
Wolverine of the Year - most over-used character
Batman
18 (26.1%)
Hal Jordan
8 (11.6%)
Deadpool
27 (39.1%)
Damian Wayne
7 (10.1%)
Wolverine
9 (13.0%)
Biggest Non-Event
Wonder Woman's new costume
18 (27.3%)
Shadowland
7 (10.6%)
Superman Grounded
29 (43.9%)
Brightest Day
12 (18.2%)
Worst Retcon
Ice's origin story in JLI: Gen Lost
28 (40.6%)
Wonder Woman new origin
23 (33.3%)
Babs was spurred on to become Oracle because of Bruce in Oracle: The Road Home
15 (21.7%)
Martian Manhunter not the first martian
3 (4.3%)
Plot Hole of The Year
Clark Kent misses whole year at the Planet
31 (55.4%)
Lex Luthor gets his company back
13 (23.2%)
Martian Manhunter not the first martian
12 (21.4%)
Meme Inspiring Moment
“Tiny but loud”
9 (16.1%)
At least Wonder Woman has pants!
38 (67.9%)
Diana meeting Superman
9 (16.1%)
A Promise Fulfilled Award -for a long awaited series or event
Red Hood: The Lost Days
26 (41.9%)
Return of Bruce Wayne
21 (33.9%)
The death in the Fantastic Four family
10 (16.1%)
First Wave
5 (8.1%)
Most Unexpected Plot Twist - SPOILER ALERT
Batman, Inc and the franchising of Batman
41 (74.5%)
Weaponer joins the Sinestro Corps
14 (25.5%)
Worst Kept Secret of the Year – a really really non-surprising twist
Jaime Reyes fake out death
22 (30.6%)
New Krypton going the way of Old Krypton
6 (8.3%)
Bruce Wayne IS ALIVE
36 (50.0%)
Captain America IS ALIVE
6 (8.3%)
Flash Thompson as Venom
2 (2.8%)
Most Dearly Departed -Good books that were canceled this past year
Azrael
2 (3.3%)
Thor: The Mighty Avenger
40 (65.6%)
Agents of ATLAS
6 (9.8%)
REBELS
8 (13.1%)
Guardians of the Galaxy
5 (8.2%)
Best Title Resurrection
Biggest Purchase Regret
Mark Millar's Nemesis
11 (20.8%)
Batman and Robin issues by Paul Cornell
3 (5.7%)
Brightest Day
13 (24.5%)
Batman Widening Gyre
15 (28.3%)
Gotham City Sirens
8 (15.1%)
What If? Venom
3 (5.7%)
You Look Familiar – Artist with the most indistinguishable faces
Nothing Works That Way Artwork Award
Guillem March
17 (32.1%)
Secret Six cover with Black Alice on the gravestone
14 (26.4%)
Humberto Ramos
22 (41.5%)
Most Improvement shown by an Artist or Writer
The Green Manties -for largest amount of male fanservice
Red Hood: Lost Days
27 (49.1%)
Batman Return of Bruce Wayne #1
9 (16.4%)
Thor titles
19 (34.5%)
The Power Window -for largest amount of female fanservice
The Best Fanservice Award
Jeremy Haun: Red Hood Lost Days
15 (26.8%)
Amanda Conner
17 (30.4%)
Gail Simone for Birds of Prey
24 (42.9%)
A Life Less Ordinary – Most Positive portrayal of LGBTQ
Most Positive portrayal of the differently abled -both physically and mentally
Oracle, Birds of Prey
33 (56.9%)
Misty Knight in Heroes for Hire
13 (22.4%)
Superior by Mark Millar
4 (6.9%)
Beasts of Burden - animals have feelings too
8 (13.8%)
Most Diverse Cast
Best Artist
Jock
1 (1.6%)
Dustin Nguyen
15 (23.4%)
JH Williams III
7 (10.9%)
Francis Manapul
3 (4.7%)
Skottie Young
3 (4.7%)
Nicola Scott
6 (9.4%)
Amanda Conner
9 (14.1%)
Marcus To
3 (4.7%)
Cameron Stewart
0 (0.0%)
Doug Mahnke
0 (0.0%)
Jeremy Haun
1 (1.6%)
Ming Doyle
1 (1.6%)
Janet Lee
0 (0.0%)
Phil Noto
4 (6.2%)
Cliff Chiang
0 (0.0%)
Sean Murphy
1 (1.6%)
Mauro Cascioli
0 (0.0%)
Yildiray Cinar
1 (1.6%)
George Perez
9 (14.1%)
Best Writer
Scott Snyder
1 (1.6%)
Gail Simone
24 (38.7%)
Brian Michael Bendis
1 (1.6%)
Jeff Lemire
1 (1.6%)
Bryan Q. Miller
7 (11.3%)
Kathryn Immonen
1 (1.6%)
Grant Morrison
7 (11.3%)
J.T.Krul
1 (1.6%)
Fabian Nicieza
5 (8.1%)
Bluefall, for her piece on the Bana
10 (16.1%)
Geoff Johns
4 (6.5%)
Best Comic of the Year You Probably Haven't Heard Of.
Best Independent Book
The Return of the Dapper Men
3 (7.3%)
Quarter-Life Crisis
1 (2.4%)
Irredeemable
25 (61.0%)
Skyworld
3 (7.3%)
Beasts of Burden
9 (22.0%)
Best DC Book
Secret Six
10 (16.4%)
Batgirl
25 (41.0%)
Powergirl
3 (4.9%)
Red Hood: Lost Days
8 (13.1%)
Batman Inc.
7 (11.5%)
Birds of Prey
5 (8.2%)
REBELS
3 (4.9%)
Best Marvel Book
New Avengers
11 (22.9%)
Wolverine and Jubilee
7 (14.6%)
Avengers Vs. Pet Avengers
6 (12.5%)
Thor the Mighty Avenger
21 (43.8%)
Incredible Hulks
3 (6.2%)
Best All Ages Book
Comic We'd Spend Our Last $5 on.
Batman Inc.
11 (18.3%)
Batgirl 1
30 (50.0%)
Thor the Mighty Avenger
15 (25.0%)
Incredible Hulk 611
4 (6.7%)
The Lifetime Achievement Award
Dwayne McDuffie
48 (81.4%)
Perry Moore 1
4 (6.8%)
Adrienne Roy
3 (5.1%)
Harvey Pekar
4 (6.8%)
"Any votes for Beasts of Burden - animals have feelings too under the category of Most Positive portrayal of the differently abled -both physically and mentally will be ignored. I was stupid to have included this nomination. I'm sorry. --Salad Barbarian"
no subject
Date: 2011-03-26 01:12 am (UTC)no subject
Date: 2011-03-26 01:14 am (UTC)no subject
Date: 2011-03-26 01:25 am (UTC)Okay, wow, this falls into the "really not right" category, something I did not expect to see in this community.
Lumping portrayals of people with disabilities in with dogs and cats is just not right and isn't how this anti-ableist, anti-oppression thing is supposed to work.
no subject
Date: 2011-03-26 02:11 am (UTC)no subject
Date: 2011-03-26 02:15 am (UTC)+1
Date: 2011-03-26 02:17 am (UTC)This
Date: 2011-03-26 02:20 am (UTC)no subject
Date: 2011-03-26 02:44 am (UTC)no subject
Date: 2011-03-26 11:41 am (UTC)no subject
Date: 2011-03-26 02:22 am (UTC)no subject
Date: 2011-03-26 01:09 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2011-03-26 02:59 pm (UTC)Being lumped into the same category with animals is only offensive for people if they think of animals being LESS than human. And that thought is oppressive, too.
(Really, I am not trying to start a fight or anything, just think of this as food for thought, at least?)
no subject
Date: 2011-03-26 03:17 pm (UTC)We don't say an infant has a disability because it can't feed itself. We don't say a US citizen stuck in Japan has a disability because she can't read or speak Japanese and doesn't understand the local money. And we don't say a dog has a disability because it can't unlock a door with a key.
If the category had included, oh, a comic version of Diefenbaker from Due South, or Greebo from Discworld, those might've made sense. (Hypothetically. Dief being deaf and Greebo's missing eye are both treated more like plot mcguffins than actual disabilities.) But a comic about a group of able-bodied animals definitely doesn't belong on the list.
no subject
Date: 2011-03-26 03:28 pm (UTC)Thank you for clarifying :)
no subject
Date: 2011-03-26 03:44 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2011-03-26 02:27 am (UTC)'Cuz, seriously, the current Arsenal look might be worse than 2 or 3 of his 6 previous costumes (Arsenal mark iv, Red Arrow, and arguably Speedy), but it's better than the other three (seriously, Roy's taste in costumes sucks) OR Mon-El's Green Lantern look.
no subject
Date: 2011-03-26 02:30 am (UTC)Mind you, I don't really mind the FF costume, although it'd be hell to keep clean in New York.
no subject
Date: 2011-03-26 11:49 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2011-03-26 02:47 am (UTC)no subject
Date: 2011-03-26 03:52 am (UTC)no subject
Date: 2011-03-26 04:22 am (UTC)no subject
Date: 2011-03-26 07:14 am (UTC)