A Year In The JSA: 2009 (issues 23-28)
Aug. 14th, 2024 08:21 am![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
Geoff Johns' final story arc involves Black Adam (but of course), then there's something of a fill-in arc by Jerry Ordway. The Black Adam stuff... eh, it's fine. It's following up on 52, and of course one of the problems with 52 is that if you're just going a read-through of, say, Renee Montoya, then it's a bit of a time-sink to have her involved in a 52 issue anthology sorta series. Adam's also been in Countdown, Final Crisis, multiple minis... at this point, I have to ask, is he really that popular or was DC just trying again and again to have symmetry with the Rock movie that was in development hell forever?
Okay, point is (thanks Wikipedia), Adam has loved and lost and is desperate to resurrect Isis. He's also killed millions of people at this point, which makes the odd kid gloves treatment he receives for having a code of honor or whatevs seem ridiculous. Yeah, Captain Nazi is a prick and all, but even he hasn't killed a percentage point of the global population.
Anyway, Adam is dealt with and the status quo of the Rock of Eternity changes yet again. Then Ordway's story, which is about a Japanese supervillain who wants to get revenge on the JSA for the bombing of Hiroshima, complete with g-g-g-g-ghosts! Yeah. It all feels a bit overwritten and wordy, clunky in a way that, say, I don't recall Ordway's work on Shazam being. Like the editors didn't bother too much getting it up to snuff because it was a nostalgia play. I don't know, it didn't work for me, it didn't not work for me, it was kinda just there.
Lastly, here's Johns' final issue, which eschews any superhero plotting to just be about the Society celebrating Courtney's birthday.
( Read more... )
Okay, point is (thanks Wikipedia), Adam has loved and lost and is desperate to resurrect Isis. He's also killed millions of people at this point, which makes the odd kid gloves treatment he receives for having a code of honor or whatevs seem ridiculous. Yeah, Captain Nazi is a prick and all, but even he hasn't killed a percentage point of the global population.
Anyway, Adam is dealt with and the status quo of the Rock of Eternity changes yet again. Then Ordway's story, which is about a Japanese supervillain who wants to get revenge on the JSA for the bombing of Hiroshima, complete with g-g-g-g-ghosts! Yeah. It all feels a bit overwritten and wordy, clunky in a way that, say, I don't recall Ordway's work on Shazam being. Like the editors didn't bother too much getting it up to snuff because it was a nostalgia play. I don't know, it didn't work for me, it didn't not work for me, it was kinda just there.
Lastly, here's Johns' final issue, which eschews any superhero plotting to just be about the Society celebrating Courtney's birthday.
( Read more... )
A Year In The JSA: 2009 (issues 19-22)
Aug. 13th, 2024 01:17 pm![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
The Thy Kingdom Come story arc continues on and as you might expect from countless TOS episodes, Gog turns out to be a 'god' whose drawbacks outweigh his positives, so he's summarily superhero-battled. All his miracles are undone, aside from Lance's transformation into Magog, and the toys are firmly put back in the box. Power Girl comes back from Earth-2 and everything.
I hold that this three-TPB arc probably could've wrapped up sooner, as Gog pretty self-evidently was going to turn out to be a rotter the whole time, but let's not get into pacing in superhero comics.
Kingdom Come Superman returns to his own world too, leaving me feeling it was all a bit pointless to give him a big adventure in-between panels of KC. It just feels to me that if he had days or weeks to process what he thought had happened with Captain Marvel, he wouldn't have been in the state he was in. But then, I don't hold KC to be such a sacred cow that I don't think an author can take a big swing on it. Just "oh, that's been around long enough that we're getting nostalgic riffs on it? Kay."
Which brings us to Magog.
( Read more... )
I hold that this three-TPB arc probably could've wrapped up sooner, as Gog pretty self-evidently was going to turn out to be a rotter the whole time, but let's not get into pacing in superhero comics.
Kingdom Come Superman returns to his own world too, leaving me feeling it was all a bit pointless to give him a big adventure in-between panels of KC. It just feels to me that if he had days or weeks to process what he thought had happened with Captain Marvel, he wouldn't have been in the state he was in. But then, I don't hold KC to be such a sacred cow that I don't think an author can take a big swing on it. Just "oh, that's been around long enough that we're getting nostalgic riffs on it? Kay."
Which brings us to Magog.
( Read more... )
A Year In The JSA: 2008 (issues 13-18)
Aug. 12th, 2024 04:28 am![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
So the actual plot of Thy Kingdom Come--yeah, we're still on that story--involves Magog, the antihero in Kingdom Come who killed the Joker and kicked off the superhero Dark Age. He's running around, killing demigod-styled supervillains as false gods (weirdly he doesn't get to Maxie Zeus, who is the only god wannabe I can think of, but maybe he was already dead at the time). Kingdom Come Superman wants to stop him so he can't bring about the comparatively bad future of KC.
This gets a little complicated, but Magog turns out to be not THE Magog, but fighting him leads the JSA to Gog, a god of the Third World (those guys who preceded Apokolips and New Genesis). Gog wakes up, is kaiju-sized, and starts wandering around Africa, performing miracles and gathering a literal following.
(Amazing Man, who you'd think would be the most opinionated about all things African, has surprisingly little to say about all this.)

( Read more... )
This gets a little complicated, but Magog turns out to be not THE Magog, but fighting him leads the JSA to Gog, a god of the Third World (those guys who preceded Apokolips and New Genesis). Gog wakes up, is kaiju-sized, and starts wandering around Africa, performing miracles and gathering a literal following.
(Amazing Man, who you'd think would be the most opinionated about all things African, has surprisingly little to say about all this.)

( Read more... )
A Year In The JSA: 2008 (issues 7-12)
Aug. 11th, 2024 03:12 am![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
Having finished with the massive crossover of The Lightning Saga, it's time for... another massive crossover, with Kingdom Come. The fact that it's with 1-2 characters from that story, and it's one of the most iconic stories the DC has, does make it a bit more tolerable. But here's where Johns really starts to get jiggy with the new kids.
( Read more... )
( Read more... )
A Year In The JSA: 2007 (issues 5-6)
Aug. 10th, 2024 05:28 pm![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
This is The Lightning Saga, a crossover with Brad Meltzer's Justice League that also involves the Legion of Superheroes. (Not the then-current reboot by Mark Waid, but rather the 'classic' version)
I found it... a bunch of sound and fury, signifying very little. There's a lot going on. Three separate superteams, time travel, amnesia, resurrection, sparring, random encounters, random encounters that are really illusions, and callbacks callbacks CALLBACKS!
But at the end of the day, it struck me as borderline incoherent, leaving me having a hard time being able to say what happened, what the characters were trying to accomplish, what was getting in their way, why they were trying to accomplish it in the way they went about it...
( Spoilers for almost twenty year old comics now. )
I found it... a bunch of sound and fury, signifying very little. There's a lot going on. Three separate superteams, time travel, amnesia, resurrection, sparring, random encounters, random encounters that are really illusions, and callbacks callbacks CALLBACKS!
But at the end of the day, it struck me as borderline incoherent, leaving me having a hard time being able to say what happened, what the characters were trying to accomplish, what was getting in their way, why they were trying to accomplish it in the way they went about it...
( Spoilers for almost twenty year old comics now. )
A Year In The JSA: 2007 (issues 1-4)
Aug. 10th, 2024 02:04 am![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
A reboot of the team post-Infinite Crisis, Justice Society of America has Geoff Johns still on as writer, but a new line-up after One Year Later. The first story arc left me a little cold. It's mostly a jumping-on point kinda storyline, getting the band back together and introducing the new kids that we'll be following on this incarnation of the team. The actual plot is... there are Nazis and they're killing people and the superheroes have to stop them. It's kinda thin. Might just be me, but when the villain with the most characterization is Captain Nazi and that's just because he's shown up in other comics that give him character development... Otherwise, they're just here to back Vandal Savage's play and commit awful atrocities against women and children, which of course they greatly enjoy because they're such bad people.
It makes for a bit of a tonal clash when you're introducing a bunch of fun new characters who are 'joining the family.'
( Read more... )
It makes for a bit of a tonal clash when you're introducing a bunch of fun new characters who are 'joining the family.'
( Read more... )
A Year In The JSA: 2000 (issues 13-15)
Jul. 31st, 2024 03:16 pm![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
As you'll recall, the JSA split up to deal with both Extant and Kobra. While the Kobra mission went well, they came home to find Metron--who for the New God nobody likes, sure gets a lot of guest spots--telling them that the universe was about to be reset by an insane, power-hungry... ok, you know where this joke is going, fuck Dan Didio and let's move on.
( Read more... )
( Read more... )
A Year In The JSA: 2000 (issues 11-12)
Jul. 21st, 2024 01:46 pm![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
Time to return to the DC Universe, home of such farflung sci-fi concepts as time travel, alien life, and air travel that isn't entirely safe.
( Read more... )
( Read more... )
Die Hard in an Injustice Society (JSA 10)
Jul. 19th, 2024 05:35 pm![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
As seen last time, Wildcat is armed with nothing but a towel when the Injustice Society breaks into JSA headquarters. But, as Douglas Adams always told us, you're pretty sorted as long as you've got a towel.
( You fools, you're mooks and he's a palooka! A mook's natural predator! )
( You fools, you're mooks and he's a palooka! A mook's natural predator! )
The Flash #179
Dec. 3rd, 2023 03:34 pm![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
A bunch of Jokerized villains break Captain Boomerang out of police custody.
( Read more... )