I really like Jeff Smith's take on Billy Batson, stressing his homelessness and street toughness, yet keeping him relatively innocent.
For that matter, I liked Judd Winnick's Billy also, in the Superman/Shazam miniseries, for many of the same reasons.
I must admit to being more of the "Grown-up Billy" mindset---if the kid doesn't really CHANGE into the hero, BECOMES the hero, it ruins the wish fulfillment part of it for me. Although I admit there's been evidence both ways in the Golden Age stories.
I tend to see the Captain as Billy's personality only changed--enhanced might be a better word-- by the addition of the wisdom of Solomon and bravery of Achilles--more alert, more knoweldgable, braver, and perhaps with his Billy memories slighly crowded out, especially of the time before he became Captain Marvel, and becoming more so the longer he shared the Billy/Marvel duality.
Founded by girl geeks and members of the slash fandom, scans_daily strives to provide an atmosphere which is LGBTQ-friendly, anti-racist, anti-ableist, woman-friendly and otherwise discrimination and harassment free.
Bottom line: If slash, feminism or anti-oppressive practice makes you react negatively, scans_daily is probably not for you.
no subject
Date: 2013-01-01 06:58 pm (UTC)For that matter, I liked Judd Winnick's Billy also, in the Superman/Shazam miniseries, for many of the same reasons.
I must admit to being more of the "Grown-up Billy" mindset---if the kid doesn't really CHANGE into the hero, BECOMES the hero, it ruins the wish fulfillment part of it for me. Although I admit there's been evidence both ways in the Golden Age stories.
I tend to see the Captain as Billy's personality only changed--enhanced might be a better word-- by the addition of the wisdom of Solomon and bravery of Achilles--more alert, more knoweldgable, braver, and perhaps with his Billy memories slighly crowded out, especially of the time before he became Captain Marvel, and becoming more so the longer he shared the Billy/Marvel duality.