A Year In The JSA: 2010 (issues 34-40)
Aug. 17th, 2024 09:00 am![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
The second half of Bill Willingham's run involves a short arc about the JSA taking on Mordru, followed by one of those Days of Future Past type things where Nazis have taken over the future, so the surviving heroes have to use time travel to undo the lousy future. Nothing wrong with that, theoretically, but
1. The arc just kinda seems to wallow in the awfulness of this Nazi future. Concentration camps and whatnot. Which is par for the course for this kind of story, but I feel it should be leavened somewhat. This is entertainment, after all. I think Bill's trying to do that with a subplot about Mr. Terrific genuinely befriending his interrogator, but it's just not enough to me.
2. This stops being a 'JSA' story and becomes more of a 'DC universe' story, with cameos from just about every superhero ever. It feels elementary to me that this dystopian future arc would be a good chance to show the younger JSAers in something like their prime, answer the question of how they would react to this situation, but instead we get a lot of Ollie and Bruce and Clark and so forth. Which, ironically, makes this story feel a lot more generic.
Anyway, here are some scans.
( Read more... )
1. The arc just kinda seems to wallow in the awfulness of this Nazi future. Concentration camps and whatnot. Which is par for the course for this kind of story, but I feel it should be leavened somewhat. This is entertainment, after all. I think Bill's trying to do that with a subplot about Mr. Terrific genuinely befriending his interrogator, but it's just not enough to me.
2. This stops being a 'JSA' story and becomes more of a 'DC universe' story, with cameos from just about every superhero ever. It feels elementary to me that this dystopian future arc would be a good chance to show the younger JSAers in something like their prime, answer the question of how they would react to this situation, but instead we get a lot of Ollie and Bruce and Clark and so forth. Which, ironically, makes this story feel a lot more generic.
Anyway, here are some scans.
( Read more... )